UCSF Home UCSF Search UCSF Medical Center

 
 

 



 

Related Resources Purpose and scope of services What We Do UCSF Charter Agreement Ethical Principles IOA Standards International Ombudsman Association (IOA) Related Resources Declaration of Best Practices Contact Us IOA Code of Ethics Advantages and Disadvantages Provide Feedback About Services

 

 


 

     

 

 

 

 

Formal vs. Informal Processes

There are distinct differences between "Formal" and "Informal" procedures. The following are important elements (categorized by "Advantages" and "Disadvantages") that can help to differentiate the two courses of action.

Advantages

FORMAL

  • Due process rights outlined for disputants
  • Timetables outlines
  • "Guilty" or "Not Guilty" outcome IS possible (if desired by either/both)
  • "Paper Trail" proves what occurred
  • "Repeat offenders" tracked

INFORMAL

  • Process stays in disputants' control
  • Confidentiality easier to maintain
  • May work because of motivation to avoid formal procedures
  • Less cumbersome
  • Can result in better communication between the parties
  • Does not require "proof" to others

Disadvantages

FORMAL

  • Process is out of disputants' control
  • Time-consuming
  • Potentially embarrassing (less confidential)
  • Requires a written statement
  • Does not work well when evidence is lacking

INFORMAL

  • No discipline option available (disadvantage for some complainants)
  • No paper trail
  • Due process not guaranteed
  • No timetables
  • "Repeat offenders" cannot be tracked

 

 



Office of the Ombuds | 3333 California Street, Suite 309 | San Francisco, CA 94143-1264 | (415) 502-9600
© 2011 The Regents of the University of California. All rights reserved.

 

Ombuds Home Page Mediation Services Related Resources Contact Us